▲ stockoverlap.com
2026-11-21

How StockOverlap Tracks Every Pick vs SPY and RSP

A stock screen is only as honest as what happens after the name appears. StockOverlap publishes a public track record that logs every Dual Pick the day it is called, with its entry price frozen, then counts every pick — open and closed, winners and losers — marked to market and after an assumed trading cost. Each pick is also measured against SPY and against the equal-weight S&P 500 ETF, RSP, over the same holding window.

The figures below were read on Saturday, November 21, 2026 from the public track-record payload that /track renders. They reflect the November 20, 2026 close shown there (77 picks priced, record span May 8, 2026 to November 20, 2026). They will move on the next trading day. This is not financial advice. Nothing here is a recommendation to buy or sell any security. Past performance does not guarantee future results.

What gets logged

A Dual Pick is a stock that appears in both of StockOverlap's independent scans on the same day — a quality scan and a value scan — and clears the combined-score and analyst-upside gates. How StockOverlap finds stocks and How StockOverlap picks stocks walk through that pipeline. The methodology page documents the data sources, the scoring, and how a pick is closed.

The tracking rule is simpler than the scoring. When a pick first appears, its entry date and entry price are frozen. The only later adjustment to that entry price is for stock splits. While the pick is open, the return is measured from that frozen entry to the latest close. When it closes, the exit date, exit price, and exit reason are frozen too.

Since October 2026, the logging code only adds picks and never deletes them. That was not always true, and the earlier edits are disclosed on the same page as the totals.

Open tickers are for subscribers, so this article discusses only the open-position totals. Closed picks may be named.

How a return is measured

Each pick is counted from its frozen entry price to its exit price if it has closed, or to the latest close if it is still open. On the November 21 check, that latest close was November 20, 2026.

Every return in the headline totals is after an assumed 0.15% trading cost on each side — a buy and a sell. Open picks are treated as if they were sold at that close, so the cost is applied to them as well. Dividends are not included. SPY and RSP are also measured on a price-only basis, over each pick's own holding window.

The public page reports both the raw return after costs and the excess versus SPY, because a gain that merely matches the index is not outperformance. The closed-picks table on /track is labeled clearly: those line-by-line returns are price changes before costs. The totals above the table are after costs.

The headline is every pick, not just the closed ones

This is the figure the page tells you to start with, because closed picks alone flatter the record. Picks that rise tend to hit a target and close. Picks that fall tend to stay open. Counting only the closed book hides the unfinished losses.

After the November 20, 2026 close, the all-picks line — open plus closed, marked to market, after costs — showed:

  • 77 picks (38 open, 39 closed)
  • Average return per pick of +1.9% after costs
  • SPY, over the same holding windows: −3%
  • Excess versus SPY: +4.9 percentage points
  • Equal-weight S&P 500 (RSP), same windows: −0.1%
  • 67.5% of picks ahead of SPY
  • 53.2% of picks with a gain after costs
  • Record so far: 196 days, from May 8, 2026 to November 20, 2026

The page is explicit that this is under 12 months, so nothing on it is annualized. This article follows that rule.

A second block shows a hypothetical equal-weight portfolio of every Dual Pick held on each trading day, starting from $10,000: +3% cumulative after costs, versus −6.5% for buying and holding SPY and +1.6% for RSP over the same period, with a maximum drawdown of −8%. That block is based on 77 picks over 137 trading days. The page calls it a small sample and asks you to read it as evidence, not proof. It also notes two simplifications: positions use daily closing prices, not the entry prices in the table, and rebalancing between positions is not charged as a cost. No annualized return is shown, because the span is still under 12 months.

Closed picks, with the caveat attached

Closed picks are still worth looking at. They are just not the headline.

After the same close, the 39 closed picks showed a 79.5% win rate after costs, an average return of +10.3% after costs, and +8.5 percentage points of excess versus SPY over the same holding windows (SPY itself was +1.8% on those windows). 76.9% of closed picks beat SPY. The best closed pick returned +31.9% after costs; the worst returned −21.8% after costs.

The public table lists those closed names. Ulta Beauty (ULTA), called May 17, 2026 and closed October 23, 2026, is the best of them: the table's before-cost column shows +32.3%, and the after-cost total above is +31.9%. Rollins (ROL), called May 28, 2026 and closed November 4, 2026, is the worst: the table shows −21.5% before costs, and the after-cost total is −21.8%. Those after-cost extremes use the same 0.15%-per-side formula as the headline, applied to the entry and exit prices published on the table.

Open picks are already inside the all-picks headline. As of the November 20 close there were 38 open positions, with an average marked-to-market return of −6.8% after costs. 10 were in profit and 28 were in drawdown. The worst open position was at −52.2%. Those numbers will move. This article does not name the open tickers.

The record has been edited, and that is disclosed

In July 2026, the record was edited by hand: 6 closed picks were removed, and 17 closed picks were reopened. The 6 removed picks are not in any figure on the track record page.

Until October 2026 there was also a reopen rule: if a closed pick qualified again, it was reopened at its original entry price, which removed the earlier exit. Those exits have since been restored. A pick that qualifies again is now logged as a new pick from that later day, at that day's price. Carlisle Companies (CSL) appears twice in the closed table for that reason, as two separate holds, and so does Xylem (XYL).

Two October 2026 corrections are also disclosed. Two picks that an exit-logic bug had wrongly closed as "likely delisted" while they were still trading were reopened, so they no longer appear in the closed-picks or realized stats. Four closed picks that the old reopen rule had reopened had their original exits restored, and each later appearance is listed as a separate pick.

Exit rules have changed over time, so older closed picks may reflect earlier rules, which are described on the methodology page. Track-record figures are hypothetical results of a rules-based screen, not actual trades placed by subscribers.

How to read a number this young

A 196-day record can be informative and still be too short to treat as a settled verdict. The sample is 77 names. The closed-pick win rate looks very different from the all-picks share that finished ahead after costs, and open positions currently pull the average down. Costs are assumed, not billed from a brokerage statement. Dividends are left out, which modestly understates total return on dividend-paying stocks and on SPY and RSP, which are also handled price-only here. The useful habit is to reread the live /track page. The close date is part of the number.

StockOverlap is a research and screening tool, not a broker-dealer, investment adviser, or financial planner. This is not financial advice. Nothing on the platform, and nothing in this article, is a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold any security. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Investing involves risk, including loss of principal. Do your own research.

Read the live ledger

The figures in this post are a snapshot, checked on November 21, 2026, of what stockoverlap.com/track showed for the November 20, 2026 close. If the live page and this article ever disagree, trust the live page.

Open the public track record, or start at stockoverlap.com. For the chart screen that is not this ledger, read what Monthly Clash is and support, resistance, and trendlines on monthly charts. Full access is one plan with no locked features: $29 a month, or $290 a year (two months free), with a 3-day free trial and no credit card required. Cancel anytime from the account page.

See today's dual picks →
How StockOverlap Tracks Every Pick vs SPY and RSP — StockOverlap