Track record
Every dual pick is logged the day it's called, with its entry price frozen. The headline counts every pick — open and closed, winners and losers — marked to market and after an assumed trading cost.
All picks · open + closed · marked to market · after costs
+1.9%
Avg return per pick (after costs)
-3%
SPY, same holding windows
+4.9 pts
Excess vs SPY
-0.1%
Equal-weight S&P 500 (RSP), same windows
67.5%
Picks ahead of SPY
53.2%
Picks with a gain (after costs)
77
Picks (38 open · 39 closed)
Record so far: 196 days, May 8, 2026 to Nov 20, 2026. That's under 12 months, so nothing on this page is annualized.
Each pick counts from the entry price frozen on the day it was called to its exit price if closed, or the latest close (Nov 20, 2026) if still open. Every return is after an assumed 0.15% trading cost on each side (buy and sell; open picks as if sold at that close), excluding dividends. SPY and RSP are price-only, measured over each pick's own holding window. Open tickers are for subscribers; only these totals are public.
HYPOTHETICAL PORTFOLIO · ALL PICKS, EQUAL-WEIGHT
What $10,000 would have become split evenly across every dual pick held on each trading day — open and closed — bought at the close on the day it was called and sold at the close on its exit day, using actual daily prices and after the assumed 0.15% cost on each side.
+3%
Cumulative return (after costs)
-6.5%
SPY, same period
+1.6%
RSP, same period
-8%
Max drawdown
PORTFOLIO VALUE
Real daily closes for every pick while held (open picks through the latest close), equal-weighted, vs. buying and holding SPY and RSP over the same period
Hypothetical portfolioSPY (buy & hold)RSP (equal-weight)
Based on 77 picks over 137 trading days — still a small sample; read this as evidence, not proof. No annualized return or volatility is shown until the record covers at least 12 months; extrapolating a few months would mislead. Simplifications: positions use daily closing prices (not the entry prices in the table), and rebalancing between positions is not charged as a cost.
Open picks only · already included above
38
Open positions
-6.8%
Avg return, marked to market (after costs)
10
In profit
28
In drawdown
-52.2%
Worst open position
Open picks are still held, so these returns move daily. They are already part of the all-picks figures above. Individual open tickers are for subscribers.
Closed picks only · not the headline
79.5%
Win rate (after costs)
+10.3%
Avg return (after costs)
+1.8%
SPY, same holding windows
+8.5 pts
Excess vs SPY
76.9%
Beat SPY
+31.9%
Best pick
-21.8%
Worst pick
39
Closed picks
Closed picks alone flatter the record: picks that rise tend to hit their target and close, while picks that fall tend to stay open. That's why the headline above counts every pick.
WIN RATE BY SECTOR · CLOSED PICKS
100% · 2 picks
100% · 2 picks
100% · 2 picks
100% · 5 picks
100% · 7 picks
100% · 2 picks
60% · 5 picks
60% · 5 picks
50% · 2 picks
Returns in this table are price changes before costs; the totals above are after costs.
How the record is kept: since October 2026, the logging code only adds picks and never deletes them, and once a pick closes, its exit date, price and reason are frozen. Until October 2026 there was one exception, the reopen rule: a closed pick that qualified again was reopened at its original entry price, which removed its earlier exit. Those exits have been restored, and a pick that qualifies again is now listed as a new pick from that day, at that day's price. Earlier, the record was edited by hand: in July 2026, 6 closed picks were removed (they are not in any figure on this page) and 17 closed picks were reopened.
Correction (October 2026): two picks that an exit-logic bug had wrongly closed as "likely delisted" while they were still trading were reopened, so they no longer appear in the closed picks or realized stats. Correction (October 2026): four closed picks that the old reopen rule had reopened when they qualified again had their original exits restored; each later appearance is listed as a separate pick, dated to the day it qualified again at that day's price.
Live prices from Yahoo Finance · returns since each pick's frozen entry price · not financial advice · past performance does not guarantee future results. See data sources & methodology.
Methodology and guides
- Methodology and data sourcesData sources, scoring, exit rules and known limitations.
- The Munger 200-week moving average strategyWhere the famous 200-week moving average quote comes from, what the indicator measures, when it misleads, and how StockOverlap uses it as an entry filter.
- How to find undervalued quality stocksEvery threshold in StockOverlap's quality and value scans, the hard knockouts, and how to use the same logic on any screener.
- How StockOverlap picks stocksThe full pipeline from universe to Dual Pick: two scans, the overlap, the gates, frozen entry prices and the rules that close a pick.
- Quality stocks near 52-week lows: a checklistA plain 52-week-low list compared with a quality-first screen, using what Buffett and Munger actually wrote, plus a value-trap checklist.